Taxes on a $3M Retirement Portfolio: What You'll Actually Owe Each Year

Most people assume retirement taxes are based on how much they withdraw. The real problem is what the IRS eventually forces them to withdraw.

In this episode, James walks through what taxes can actually look like on a $3 million retirement portfolio and why two retirees with the exact same amount saved can end up with completely different tax bills.

The difference is not the portfolio size. It is where the money lives. Traditional IRAs, Roth accounts, brokerage accounts, Social Security, and required minimum distributions all interact differently once retirement begins. What looks manageable at 65 can quietly become a much larger tax problem in your seventies and eighties if the wrong accounts are doing all the heavy lifting.

James breaks down how required distributions, Medicare surcharges, and shifting tax brackets can reshape retirement over time, along with why Roth conversions and account diversification create far more flexibility than most people realize.

Because retirement tax planning is not about avoiding taxes completely. It is about deciding when you pay them and making sure the IRS does not make that decision for you later.

Learn the tips & strategies to get the most out of life with your money.

--

Advisory services are offered through Root Financial Partners, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. This content is intended for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Viewing this content does not create an advisory relationship. We do not provide tax preparation or legal services. Always consult an investment, tax or legal professional regarding your specific situation.

The strategies, case studies, and examples discussed may not be suitable for everyone. They are hypothetical and for illustrative and educational purposes only. They do not reflect actual client results and are not guarantees of future performance. All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal.

Comments reflect the views of individual users and do not necessarily represent the views of Root Financial. They are not verified, may not be accurate, and should not be considered testimonials or endorsements

Participation in the Retirement Planning Academy or Early Retirement Academy does not create an advisory relationship with Root Financial. These programs are educational in nature and are not a substitute for personalized financial advice. Advisory services are offered only under a written agreement with Root Financial.

Create Your Custom Strategy ⬇️

Get Started Here.

Join the new Root Collective HERE!

Transcript

The Listener’s Retirement Snapshot

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Fifth question is for Ari. When can I retire? Um I am 52. My wife is 50. We want to retire August of 2029. My salary is 100,000. My wife's salary is 139,000. She works for a school district. Um my simple IRA, I contribute $21,000 a year. My wife contributes to our 403B Roth, $32,500 a year. Her TRS3 plan is at 5% a month, which is $500 per month. Our superhero account, we contribute $1,000 a month, and we both were maxed out our Roth IRAs, which is a total of $17,200 per month. My HFA has $15,000 in it. These are the balances. My wife Viva account has $35,000 in it. My wife 403D has $96,000 in it. Her 403B Roth has $26,000 in it. Her TRS3 plan has $161,000. My $401K has $147,000. My IRA account has $152,000. My Roth Ira account has $170,000. My wife Roth IRA has $133,000. We have about $227,000. My Superhero account has $865,000. My checking account has $25,000. My wife will receive a pension of about $3,000 a month at $65,000. We don't know when we're going to pick our full security yet. And we own two homes. They are both completely paid off. Washington House is work about $650,000, and our vacation home in Arizona is worth about $500. We would love to retire at $10,000 per month. And I would love to get any advice from you. And I appreciate you doing this. Hopefully I gave you everything you needed.

Early Retirement Goals And Tradeoffs

SPEAKER_01 1:38

This person said they want to retire at 52 and 50 in 2029. They have August, they have their month picked out, so they are ready to go. That tells me they do want to retire early. Now, I honestly don't care how much someone makes. I do care how much they're saving. But when this person's explaining all their different accounts, one, it's very difficult to understand. Okay, is everything talking to each other? And I see this a lot when people are wondering, okay, do I have the right investment mix? It's not necessarily, okay, stocks and bonds, but what do I put in every account? We've got the 43B, we've got the Vivo, we have Roth IRAs, we have superhero account, we have stocks. Now, I'm going to walk through how I would think through this. Before we get started, this is a small snapshot of this person's situation. I don't know how much they want to leave behind. I don't know if they have kids. I don't know if they rather work longer so that they can keep their vacation home or if they'd rather retire earlier and sell that. There's so many different options and alternatives here. It's going to be fun, which is why I love doing this. So I'll walk through what a typical certified financial planner, CFP, may consider in a situation like this. But once again, this is not personalized financial advice. That's important. I'm Ari, host of the Early Retirement Podcast. And if you want to retire early one day, aka not work forever, make sure to hit subscribe so you learn all the strategies. And hopefully you have fun watching. Call the number on your screen if you want to submit your situation so I might respond in a future episode. That number is 213-316-8397. You can also see it on my screen, wherever my brilliant editors put it. So I'd have a few questions before I would give any insights here. And obviously, this is never financial advice, but the first thing I would say, honestly, and I'm laughing, is hey, are you like enjoying life today? You're saving a lot of money. Now, if you're like, hey, we're naturally people, we don't, we're not big spenders, we're not worried about, hey, are we missing out on travel opportunities? We just want to retire early. That's our goal. Then I wouldn't have concerns. But if you were like, yeah, we don't go out to eat, but we'd love to because we're saving every last dollar to our investment accounts, that's where I'd caution them on doing so. Because it becomes a question of what's the highest lever opportunity. This person saved. They have $2 million plus dollars. They've saved well. They have a pension coming at 65, 3,000 a month. Their Social Security. I'm not really worried about their later retirements. In fact, I'm not even really worried about their earlier retirement. I'm worried about are they going to be able to retire and enjoy it? Because you don't want to retire too early and go,

Testing The $10K Monthly Target

SPEAKER_01 3:50

why didn't I work a few more years to spend what I actually wanted to? But you also don't want to work unnecessarily when you're like, look, I could be retired right now and still be okay. So they want to retire in three years. That's awesome. 10,000 a month, that's a good amount of money. Now that's what I like here. If someone wants to spend $120,000 a year, they might hear something like the 4% rule. Take $120,000, divide that by 0.04, and that tells you you might need $3 million if you wanted, once again, to use the 4% rule. So if this person wasn't financially savvy, and it sounds like they actually are, they are interested in retiring early. They might hear that and go, oh, we're going to work until we have $3 million. But the reality is there's a pension. The reality is there will be Social Security at some point. So it's not as if everything is fully reliant on their portfolio. Plus, they have a vacation home. I don't know if they rent that out when they're not there. There's a lot of options here. I was concerned hearing the beginning of the message because I was hearing a lot of qualified rich sentiments. If you don't know what that is, there's a term called house rich cash poor, where the majority of your money is in your home. So although you have this asset, it's not creating income for you. Meaning you might have a 10 million net worth, but if 9 million of it is in a home you never want to sell, it doesn't create income for you. It just looks good on your balance sheet. The good news is there is a superhero account. And between their stocks and superhero account, I don't really know why they separate those unless it's for mental accounting. You know, there's north of a million dollars there. So that could very easily help bridge that gap until they can touch their 401k, 403B, VIBA, pension starts, and things like that. What I would urge this person to do is get really clear on their actual expenses. They said 10,000 a month. I don't think that's right. And I've shared that with people. And they're like, well, how do you do not think that's right? Like that's me telling you my thoughts. Your opinion is irrelevant here. I said, I'm not discounting the 10,000. I'm saying most people spend more when they have their energy and health. So if you wanted to spend more, would that be attractive? And some people go, of course, who would not want more? But some people would go, no, honestly, I wouldn't know what to do with more than that. So I'm asking the question to gauge how they respond, not necessarily what the response is. So if I ask you, hey, would you like to spend more than 10,000 a month? And you go, of course, who wouldn't? I go, okay, 12,000 a month? Could you do everything you want and more? They'd go, yeah, that's actually two more big trips. That'd be fun. I go, great. 12,000 a month might be the goal. Do you think you're gonna spend more or less compared to your 50s versus 70s? They might go, oh, maybe less in my 70s. I don't have the same health and energy. I'm not traveling to the same degree. I'm like, great, okay, well, that's good to know. Because if we're gonna spend maybe 9,000 a month, then that changes how you can retire early because you might spend more at the beginning, and then later on, you have a pension, you have Social Security, and you're spending less, which means there's

Taxes, Healthcare, And Next Steps

SPEAKER_01 6:18

less requirement on your portfolio. We don't need it to be as large, which allows you to retire earlier and enjoy more. And there's a risk to overspending, but there's also a huge risk of regret, which most people don't focus on. Okay, maybe at this point in your life you want to practice retirement, see how much you want to travel. They said they own two homes. Do they want to sell a home? If they do sell a home and there's a big capital gain, how does that impact healthcare? Are they planning on doing what's called tax gain harvesting? If not, I'd strongly consider looking into it because you can see here I put out this episode. This is exactly how you can retire and spend $10,000 a month or $120,000 a year and pay 0% taxes and how to do that. So if I'm this person, that's basically exactly what they told me they wanted to spend. Is that accounting for healthcare? Is that accounting for extra trips? I don't know. What do you guys think of this person's situation? Let me know in the comments what advice, what feedback would you actually want to give them if they were hypothetically your client? Whether or not you're a financial advisor, you can give your feedback. It's a free country here. So a few options. Number one, obviously, comment optimize below. If you want to go build your own plan with the software I use in my videos. Number two, if you just want a free guide that just helps you understand you're not forgetting anything before you retire, comment retire. And then finally, if you're like, okay, I want to make sure I don't mess something up. I want to speak to you and your team. Okay, well, this is what we love to do. So you can, of course, go to rootfinancial.com. In the upper right, there's a little button that says see if you're a fit. Answer a few questions. We might talk very soon. And then, of course, once again, the number if you want to call to leave your voicemail where I might respond in a future episode. 213 316 8397 to submit your situation of having me potentially respond in the future. Thanks as always. Please like and comment what fascinated you the most about this episode. I'll see you guys next time. Love ya.